From Scottish Highlands to Kaku-highballs: the rise and rise of Japanese whisky
TOKYO —
Director: Mr Bob-san. [In Japanese] You’re relaxing in your study. There’s a bottle of Suntory whisky on the table. You understand, right? Say it with intense feeling, slowly, looking at the camera, tenderly, as if to an old friend. Like Bogie in Casablanca: “Here’s looking at you kid…” Suntory Time.
Interpreter: He wants you to turn, look in camera. OK?
Bob: That’s all he said?
It was a drink with decades of history behind it. But until Bill Murray cradled a glass of Suntory Hibiki in Sofia Coppola’s “Lost in Translation,” most Westerners probably had no idea that Japanese whisky even existed.
The film’s release was well timed, in that respect. It hit screens in 2003, the year in which Suntory’s Yamazaki 12 Years Old became the first Japanese whisky to win a gold medal at the prestigious International Spirits Challenge (ISC) in London. Two years earlier, Whisky Magazine had proclaimed Nikka’s 10-year-old Yoichi the “best of the best.” Once all but unknown outside its domestic market, Japanese whisky was finally going places.
Since then, the accolades have been piling up. Suntory’s Hibiki 30 Years won the “Trophy,” the ISC’s highest prize, in 2004—and again in 2006, 2007 and 2008. Yamazaki 18 Years snagged the Double Gold Award at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition in 2005. In the 2008 World Whisky Awards, Japanese distilleries won in both the Best Single Malt and Best Blended categories. Suntory was named Distiller of the Year in the 2010 Icons of Whisky awards, and again in the ISC. I could go on, but it gets a bit repetitive.
“It’s exceptional to get a competition or an international tasting where a Japanese whisky doesn’t get a prize,” says Chris Bunting, a British journalist who’s become something of an authority on Japanese single malts. A favorable evening with a bottle of Yamazaki 12 Years led him to start the website Nonjatta in 2007, and it’s since become the go-to place for English information on Japanese distilleries, bars, booze shops and the whiskies themselves, free from PR puffery.
“The reason why Japanese whisky has broken through was these competitions, but really the essential break had happened before that,” he says. Whereas big-name blended brands such as Johnnie Walker used to hold sway over global tastes, there’s been a general shift in preference towards single malts, with their emphasis on individual distilleries.
“You’re taking away some very vague branding [and moving] towards something more specific,” Bunting continues. “You’re empowering this sort of priesthood of critics, who smell it and taste it and say, ‘This is, in and of itself, excellent.’ And in doing that, you are actually internationalizing it, potentially. Because you are saying that some guy in Japan could, if he does it right, do it as well.”
Hazy start in early Meiji Era
And thankfully, some guys in Japan had been laying the necessary foundations. The story of Japanese whisky gets off to a hazy start in the early Meiji Era, but it doesn’t really pick up until 1923, when Suntory founder Shinjiro Torii established the country’s first commercial distillery in the Yamazaki Valley, not far from Kyoto. Torii hired one Masataka Taketsuru, the son of a “nihonshu”-making family, who had traveled to Scotland in 1918 in order to study at the University of Glasgow—and also learn about the art of distilling.
Returning to Japan with a Scottish wife in tow, Taketsuru became the first manager of the new Yamazaki Distillery, but his staunch allegiance to authentically smoky Scotch didn’t sit well with local tastes. He soon parted ways with his employers and went on to start Nikka in 1934, opening his first distillery in Yoichi, Hokkaido; the location reminded him of Scotland. Today, Suntory remains by far the largest whisky maker in Japan, with Nikka ranking second and Kirin a poor third.
Although Japanese distillers have to import most of their barley, they also enjoy certain perks that come with the terroir. Keita Minari, Global Brand Manager for Suntory Whisky, rattles off a list of these for me, ranging from the type of wood used in casks to the way that seasonal variations in temperature and humidity affect the maturation process.
There are other differences, too. While Scottish distilleries routinely trade casks with each other in order to influence the flavor of their blends, Suntory—by necessity as much as design—produces over 100 varieties of malt whisky itself. “If you can use very different types of whiskies in one bottle, that means the whisky is going to be very, very subtle,” explains Minari. “Subtle and delicate: that’s the uniqueness of Japanese whisky.”
None of which explains why it took Japanese drinkers so long to fully embrace the drink produced in their own backyard. “Japan’s a funny market in some ways, because you often need to be told by the foreigner, from overseas, that your product is good before people actually really realize it,” says David Croll, a Tokyo-based whisky importer and distributor who also publishes the Japanese edition of Whisky Magazine. “But now I think Japanese have really caught on to the fact that what they have is fantastic, they’ve got a lot more confidence, and they’re really behind it in terms of marketing.”
One measure of this increased interest is the success of Whisky Live, the annual expo that Croll’s company organizes. First started in 2000 to mark the launch of the Japanese Whisky Magazine, the event has seen its attendance figures rise from 600 to 5,000, and spawned sister festivals from London to Taipei to Cape Town. This year’s Tokyo edition, held later this month, is expanding from one to two days for the first time, and moving from its previous home at Tokyo Big Sight in Odaiba to the classier environs of Roppongi’s Tokyo Midtown complex. (One rumored reason for the move is that the Scottish exhibitors couldn’t find any good bars to head to in Odaiba after the event was done.)
Whisky consumption increasing in Japan
Another measure, of course, is the actual consumption of whisky in Japan, which in 2009 increased for the first time in 20 years. Mind you, that didn’t have as much to do with prize-winning prestige brands as it did with Suntory’s enormously successful campaign to promote whisky highballs as the izakaya tipple of choice. Though the company’s sales push has been focused on mass-market brands—first Kakubin, now the even cheaper Tory’s—it’s done a lot to help raise the profile of whisky in general.
“In the past, customers who preferred beer usually started off with one of those when they came in,” says Atsushi Horigami, the owner of Japanese whisky haven Shot Bar Zoetrope in Shinjuku. “Now, a lot of customers ask me to recommend a nice highball that isn’t too expensive instead.”
Horigami opened Zoetrope five years ago, leaving behind a career in video game production, and he’s well placed to observe recent trends in the market. In his eyes, one of the brightest stars at the moment is Ichiro Akuto, an independent distiller who’s in the process of resurrecting his family’s old whisky business.
The original Hanyu distillery closed in 2000 after its parent company went bankrupt, but Akuto was able to save its stocks, and is now reselling them under the Ichiro’s Malt label via his own company, Venture Whisky. In 2008, production commenced at a new distillery in Chichibu, Saitama Prefecture, and advance word has been very positive indeed.
“Venture Whisky are distilling like crazy,” says Horigami. “They may be a small concern, but they’re actually producing the most out of anyone at the moment.”
“I think small producers will get a lot more attention in the future,” he predicts, also mentioning Eigashima’s White Oak distillery in Hyogo, and the surprise reopening of Hombo Spirits’ Mars Whisky distillery in Nagano. “I know that Suntory and Nikka aren’t going to stop, and they understand quality, so I think they’ll carry on making interesting products in the future too.”
On a more global level, Japan could face increased competition from countries that are nurturing whisky industries of their own, including South Africa, Taiwan and even India. But if its whiskies are unlikely ever to be the cheapest, there’s no arguing with their quality.
“I think Japan, long term, is really well-suited to becoming one of the major players,” says Croll. “It’s not going to have a hundred distilleries like Scotland, but I think it’s going to have a smaller number of very high quality distillers.”
And if the country’s whiskies are enjoying a particularly golden period at the moment, there’s no reason to assume that their luster will dim. “They are a bit like BMWs or Mercedes—there is some intrinsic quality to them,” says Bunting. “No doubt, they won’t be so fashionable in 20 years’ time, but they will still be very good.”
Whisky Live 2011
Whisky tastings, masterclasses and much more. Feb 19-20, 11 a.m.-6 p.m., 5,000 yen (one day)/9,000 yen (two days). Tokyo Midtown, Roppongi.
Detailed Japanese whisky news and reviews can be found at http://nonjatta.blogspot.com. Chris Bunting’s “Drinking Japan” will be released later in the year by Tuttle Publishing.
Editor’s note: No whisky was consumed in the writing of this article.
This story originally appeared in Metropolis magazine (www.metropolis.co.jp)





![[ UR ] CODE: 79257](http://www.realestate.co.jp/rej/image/193/245841-58x58-c.png)



Order by Time Order by Popularity
38 Comments
Login to comment
0
Sarge
"Mr. Bob-san. You're relaxing in your study."
I wish I had a study to relax in.
After seeing the other whiskey article in Metropolis I decided to try the 12 year old Taketsuru now produced by Nikka. One respected whiskey reviewer said it's like licking the fat from a frying pan, while the writer of the article said he's wrong, it's totally quaffable with chocolate mint dominating. Well, I taste no fat or chocolate mint, but I like it.
At 2,400 yen for 660ml that was the cheapest of the six whiskeys in the article. Heck, I can get 750 ml of perfectly good Four Roses or Early Times for around 1,200 yen.
0
DentShop
One thing about the Japanese is, if you want something top quality - someone is doing it here.
Amazing sportscars, top notch beef, fabulous women and some super-duper whiskey.
Think I might stay another 6 months...
0
yabits
Great article! -- Although I'm more of a fan of bourbon.
0
gaijintraveller
Sean Connery, a famous Scot, used to advertise Japanese whisky, but only in Japan. It would have been bad for his image if those ads had been viewed in his homeland, where his is considered a nationalist.
0
paulinusa
Just compare any of the Johnnie Walker whiskies with the Suntory Yamazaki and the Yamazaki wins hands down. If you compare the Nikka Yoichi to the Yamazaki the Yamazaki is smoother and smells like butterscotch to me, while the Yoichi has more intense flavors and a smoky smell. Unless you only want a cheap high I would avoid the highballs with the inexpensive Japanese brands, they taste really bad.
0
ebisen
I never understood whiskey, but I know a lot of gaijin saying the Japanese one is among the best. Of course is expensive, as any good alcoholic drink should be.
Blue Sapphire Bombay Gin (no rocks) on the other hand :)) yes - this is the drink the whiskey drinkers should go to after they grow up...
0
paulinusa
I can buy Yamazaki 750 ml for about $38 US and from what I remember it was substantially higher in Japan. It's always really puzzling how Japanese prices for domestic goods are set.
0
cactusJack
Japan had the sake boom,the beer boom, the wine boom, the hopposhu boom. Now it is whiskey boom. Next is the ____ boom. It is an ongoing cycle.
0
shirokuma2011
Ichiro Akuto also produced one of the best bourbon whiskeys I've ever had--since bourbon can only be produced in the U.S., he had to go over there to source and finish the product--and it was a sad day when I finished the last of the bottle with some bartender friends, knowing the chances of finding another would be very slim indeed (miraculously, another bartender friend found a half-bottle at a liquor shop near Tokyo station, and persuaded the owner to part with it...).
There must be something to the Japanese whisky (not whiskey) brands to consistently place in the top ranks in these prestigious international competitions, despite the naysayers. I prefer bourbon, so I don't have an opinion one way or the other, but it's too bad the whisky "boom" in Japan has been built (entirely by the distillers themselves) on their lowest grades of product; I guess getting young people, suckled as they've been on chuhai and cassis-orange, to drink the better whiskys straight, as they should be enjoyed, would be too much of an uphill battle for the marketers.
0
paulinusa
shirokuma2011: Perhaps it's the peculiar marketing techniques of Japanese non-alcoholic and alcoholic drink companies who always come up with hundreds of concoctions every year. Or maybe even though those highballs are cheap, they're still very profitable.
0
forinagai
Many of the distilleries in Scotland are owned by Japanese companies - is it possible that some of the techniques used in Scotland are brought back to Japan?
I don't know much about whisky and single malts, but I do know that many Japanese blended whisky brands contain malts from Scotland.
0
BurakuminDes
I wouldn't pay top dollar for a Japanese whiskey - the scots and Irish have the 15-18 year old plus market covered, IMO. But even the cheap Japanese whiskeys are good - 1000 yen ones. Good on ice or as mixers. Some Japanese drops are waaay better than the comparable 1000 yen ones ie Johnny Walker Red.
0
Stranger_in_a_Strange_Land
I prefer bourbon or Jack Daniels. Nice and sweet.
0
rockbuster
If we are talking whisky then the Macallan 18 year old single malt is a very high quality drop. A bit expensive but well worth it and seems to be readily available in Japan. For something a little cheaper, a Glenmorangie single malt is a very good alternative.
As for blends, much of a muchness IMO. The Japanese blends hold their own against competitors. Can't say I'm a bourbon man to be honest - a bit sweet for me.
0
nandakandamanda
Don't like whisky (whiskey) and I am not a whisky drinker. Tried and tried and tried. But then last summer I drank some Yamazaki 12 with ice and water and it was brilliant.
0
BurakuminDes
I hear ya man! Great scotch. Comparatively cheap in Japan too, if you buy at a big international liquor shop - this sells for double the price back home in Aus!
0
Tamarama
I have long savored the smoky peat flavour of Laphroaig, but I have to confess I haven't tried anything other than Nikka in Japan. Clearly, I will have to reconsider!
0
himehentai
I like to think of myself as somewhat of a (Scottish) whisky die hard fan, and If Im honest I roll my eyes at anyone using the word whisky and "Jack Daniels" in the same sentence.
The Scots do It best in my opinion, However I think its the distillery experience which do It for me. There is nothing like going on a tour of the distillery in a tiny valley in the middle of nowhere (Ie Scotland) In the freezing cold and then enjoying samplings and getting a little bit drunk. Japanese Whisky (Whiskey??) Is good ... but just not on the same level for me Im afraid.
Interestingly though, the last time I was in Scotland the same Whiskys were cheaper in Japan. But none the less I need to go back to Scotland. I love that country.
0
USNinJapan2
Single malt: Edradour 10 Blended: Ballantine's 30
Nothing else for me thanks.
0
Ah_so
Real whisky is not to everyone's taste!
However, Japan does seem to have plenty of excellent whisky, unlike their attempts to brew wine. If only it were not diluted so much, I could really enjoy it.
0
DentShop
Dude - save the stress on your optic nerve. Jack is whiskey. It isnt bourbon - but it is whiskey.
Ohh Laphroaig - nobody knows quite how to pronounce it but boy is it good (warning: may cause prison)
0
Sarge
A drunk is brought before a judge. The judge says, "You've been brought here for drinking whiskey."
The drunks says "OK, let's get started."
A guy walks into a bar and orders a whiskey. He gulps it down, peeks into his shirt pocket, orders another whiskey, gulps it down, peeks into his shirt pocket, orders a 3rd, a 4th, a 5th and a 6th, each time peeking into his shirt pocket after gulping it down. He then asks for the tab, pays, and starts to walk out when the bartender says, What's in your shirt pocket that you keep looking at? The guy replies, "I have a picture of my wife in my shirt pocket. I keep drinking until she starts to look good."
0
kurumazaka
I have grown quite fond of Ardbeg, though I like any of the Isle singles. The Arran is a splendid Highland malt (will be at the show). As far as Bourbon, has to be Makers. Lots of smack talked about JD, but it is a good mixer. Don't know any of the Japanese whiskys yet, but look forward to some education.
0
ubikwit
Japan has some great whisky being made from Kansai up to Hokkaido. And with the use of a local type of oak, called Mizunara, some of the best expressions--especially those aged in the Japanese oak--are not only contending with the best coming out of Scotland, they have opened a new horizon for the barrel makers. I don't think it will be too long before we see a distillery or two--probably Glenmorangie will lead the foray--experimenting with aging in barrels made with this Mizunara oak.
On another point, I believe that it was actually Nikka that won the first internaional gold medal for a Japanese whisky, in the International Wine & Spirits Competition sometime around 2001.
Also, one of the people in quoted in the article is quoted as stating that the Japanese need foreigners to tell them that their products are good... Well, that is simply nonsense, and another statement by a foreigner who probably doesn't speak Japanese, and doesn't know much about Japanese culture--including the alcohol imbibing manifestations thereof. First of all, the Japanese have a number of extremely refined high quality fermented and distilled tipple. It takes a little ground work to become acquainted with that realm, but for most Japanese, there is more than enough variety and excellence in the Nihonshu and Shochu categories to keep them happily occupied, with room to spare.
So, the fact that there is also excellent single malt whisky being produced at various places in the country is seen as something of a novelty to many Japanese. And when they eventually do have a chance to taste some, that may open up a new horizon for them--as it has for many Japanese--or it may simply remain a novelty for the time being.
At any rate, I drink single malt whisky fairly regularly, and thoroughly enjoy Japanese Nihonshu and high quality craftsman made shochu as well. So it is great to see the presence of Japanese whisky gain prominence, and also interesting to see the rising popularity of Nihonshu overseas.
0
cleo
Can't claim to be an expert, though I do enjoy a tipple. Japanese whisky used to be far inferior to Scotch, until they abolished the alcohol tax in favour of consumption tax, and the price of good Scotch came down to reasonable levels. Since then Japanese whisky has become very drinkable. Obviously competition is a good thing.
But my favourite is still rich, peaty Bowmore. And if the price is the same, I'll go for a single-malt Scotch over a Japanese whisky any day. Och aye.
0
nandakandamanda
"Oh, Biwako Loch, I wish ye were whisky,
Biwako-Loch, och aye,
Oh Biwako Loch, I wish ye were whisky,
Then I wuld drink ye dry!" OCH AYE!!!
0
cleo
Is Biwako peaty?
0
Bratpack
ubikwit: I'm not really sure what your point is. You criticise David Croll as "a foreigner who probably doesn't speak Japanese, and doesn't know much about Japanese culture," but then basically endorse what he was saying. Japanese whisky hasn't come out of nowhere: the Yamazaki distillery opened nearly 90 years ago, and the whiskies winning international competitions now would've started being produced over a decade ago. The fact that fewer Japanese drinkers now consider the drink a "novelty" is precisely because it started winning all these awards overseas.
0
nandakandamanda
Cleo "Is Biwako peaty?"
No, but there's plenty to drink, and Yamazaki is nearby! LOL
0
kurumazaka
Cleo, if you like Bowmore 12, you will love Ardbeg 10. (full disclosure, as a member of the Ardbeg committee, it is my duty to promote it at any opportunity!)
0
rockbuster
@Burakumindes
I lived in Oz for a bit and went to buy Macallan 18 year old from a liquor store (Dan Murphy's, I think) Anyway, when I asked them for a bottle, they radioed security to escort me to a triple locked glass cabinet where two people turned the key at the same time to open the cabinet!! It was crazt, like I was asking to view 25 carat platinum ring or something!!
Can't really say I'm a big fan of Laphroig. I find it too harsh, very strong when it hits my throat.
About 15 years ago, a friend of the family bought a case of Loch Dhu (not too sure of spelling) and it is an incredible drop - almost black in colour but with amazing flavour. I had some last year and will never forget the taste, aroma & colour. Now I think it retails for around 220 pounds a bottle - and I think you can only get it from the distillery and by internet order direct to the distillery. Very expensive, but Scotch lovers everywhere should try it at least once.
0
cleo
kurumazaka - OK I'm ready to be convinced. Please send 1 bottle of Ardberg 10 under plain cover for comparison purposes.
:-) ←Happy smile of anticipation
0
forinagai
How to say Laphroaig ...sounds like LaFroy..g....Ah the Gàidhlig (Gaelic)
0
ubikwit
cleo i also enjoy a peaty dram of bowmore. as for japanese peaty single malts, nikka occassionally releases peated versions distilled at its yoichi distillery in hokkaido. and suntory also releases peated and heavily peated versions from both the yamazaki and the hakushu distilleries. get a copy of jim murray's whisky bible for some detailed tasting notes. unfortunately, a bottle of any of these japanese peated malts will cost probably twice what the official standard bottling of bowmore do.
bratpak i just don't like the condescending tone of the statement that "Japanese need to be told their products are good..." that is nonsense. there are two aspects to the reasoning: first, humility is seen as a virtue and holds a high place in traditional japanese values and thinking; second, like i said above, the japanese have some very palatable alcoholic beverages already, without question some of the best in all of asia.
whisky is a beverage that originated overseas, so it is a novelty, even if japanese are making it. there has been a whisky boom recently, but there were a couple of distilleries that closed in japan due to the poor economy in the 1990s (karuizawa and hanyu), just like a number that were closed in scotland in the 1970s thru 1990s, including port ellen and lochside. on the other hand, there is also a resurgent interested in craft made traditional japanese tipple here in japan, and a growing market abroad. the final point is that there is no traditional japanese tipple that is a high prof distilled alcohol. though there is a long history of drinking, there is no custom of drinking distilled alcohol of high proof.
0
ubikwit
@cleo and @ bratpack
please see above note, formating didn't come through.
i just made the effort to search out the article that got me interested in whisky again after many years. the article was a japan times article from 2002 that describes a whisky magazine tasting in which yoichi 10yo single cask placed first (a single malt) and sutory hibiki 21yo (a blend) placed second. at any rate, at that time i had no idea there was such a thing as good japanese whisky. the article is worth a look if you want to search it on the japan times website.
the title, "Newly noticed whiskey makers forced to diversify products" .
0
keika1628
We all know the secret to the (e) in Whisk-y . The Irish put it there to distinguish itself from the Scots . The (e) is the first letter for Erin of Eire . Anyway a bottle of Boston Club will do the job for me , I also build castles and talk to myself or sometimes turn the music up after half a bottle , I also shout and wolf whistle off the balcony at women near the end of the bottle.
0
ca1ic0cat
The Japanese whisky is good but I'll agree with Cleo on her choice of tipple.
0
CruzControl
What is suprising is the import whiskeys are to reach price parity with the domestics. A far cry from the balck market days of a few years back.
And good article since in the past few weeks I have taken on a quest to collect as many differtent types of whiskey as possible to taste and compare. 14 different types so far!
Back to top