Dissatisfaction will pave way for Japan's future
TOKYO —
Though her signature white jackets and cropped hair have captured the attention of millions of Japanese across Japan, Minister for Administrative Reforms Renho Murata will be best remembered for her infamous statement made late last year, with regard to the supercomputer speed rivalry between Japan and the People’s Republic of China.
“What’s wrong with being the world’s number 2?”
There’s no question that there’s some truth to that argument. Supercomputers cost billions of yen to develop, and Japan is certainly in no financial position to be constructing new ones for the sake of holding the world title. Ongoing reconstruction costs and paying down Japan’s leviathan of a public debt have only served to drive the point home: Japan can’t afford to waste a single penny (or yen) in these tough economic times.
There is, however, something fundamentally wrong with her statement that underlines the state of Japanese society today: a defeatist attitude, one that has resigned to the fact that Japan, despite its best efforts, will always be relegated to second place (if not further behind). “仕方がない”, many mumble. It can’t be helped.
But can it really?
At humanity’s very core, the advancement and progress of our civilization has been driven purely by dissatisfaction.Dissatisfaction is the root of human innovation. Think about it for a second. If we had been happy to use our feet as a means of transport, would we have domesticated the horse? If we had been happy with horses, what use would the automobile have been? If humans had been satisfied living in Europe, would a United States of America exist today? If people had been content with the amount of time it took to travel by steamship, why would they have been inclined to switch over to commercial air travel? There’s no question that dissatisfaction leads to innovative measures used to address (and resolve) the source of dissatisfaction itself; solutions that aren’t just competitive, but present vast advantages over the original means of achieving or doing the same tasks.
It was this mentality of dissatisfaction that led Japan to its economic miracle in the aftermath of the Second World War. Once considered the laughingstock of the automotive world, Japanese cars exceeded the reliability of their domestic-built counterparts in less than three decades. The 1973 oil crisis not only forced Japan to shift from oil-intensive heavy industries to consumer electronics, but led to a monopoly powered by exceptional quality and bulletproof construction. Japan’s ascension and current wealth is derived largely from that period of dissatisfaction, where products made and exported by the Japanese had massive advantages over the same products made elsewhere.
Today, we see much of the same attitude in other countries across the Asia-Pacific region. No longer content to be nothing more than the factory of inexpensive dollar-store variety products, China has built the longest high-speed rail network in the world and manufactures delicate, advanced aircraft parts for Boeing and Airbus. South Korea’s Samsung sells more TVs than all Japanese manufacturers’ sales combined. Even Taiwan has a winner with Acer, now the world’s largest manufacturer of notebook computers.
Though there is less growth potential to be had in consumer electronics, the above is simply an analogy for what Japan has lost: a winning mentality. Where has the strength gone? Where is the spirit of “ganbaru” that had been so prevalent just two decades ago? What has happened to the Land of the Rising Sun?
There’s no doubt that Japan has endured a lot. Since 1989, the country has gone through a housing bubble; two financial crises and is ageing faster than ever before. With weak economic prospects looking bleaker and bleaker as time goes, there is much reason for pessimism and apathy.
If history were any indication, however, positive change finds its roots in dissatisfaction with the status quo. It was dissatisfaction with the treatment of blacks that led to the African-American Civil Rights Movement and an end to racial segregation and racial discrimination. It was dissatisfaction that led to the recent democracy movement in the Middle East. It was dissatisfaction with the weakness of Japan in comparison to the world powers of 1868 that enabled the restoration of imperial rule and the modernization of Japan.
Dissatisfaction, then, is needed more than ever. In the words of former peace activist Daisaku Ikeda, “Strength is Happiness. Strength is itself victory. In weakness and cowardice there is no happiness. When you wage a struggle, you might win or you might lose. But regardless of the short-term outcome, the very fact of your continuing to struggle is proof of your victory as a human being.”
Do not give up, Japan. Be more dissatisfied with the status quo and continue to struggle to become the world’s No. 1 in whatever you do. Dissatisfaction will pave the way for the country’s future.





Order by Time Order by Popularity
12 Comments
Login to comment
0
GW
I kinda agree with this but the reality is govt & beaurocrates arent just making it hard for mere plebs, they are thwarting us.
Just this past Monday I sent an equiry to the Ministry of Finance(MOF) beacause the Japan Commercial Aribitration Association(like a Chamber of Commerce) told me they were not at liberty to discuss my inquiry, they understood it & agreed a change would be benficial to exports from Japan, but their hands were tied & said this stuff policy wise is handled by the MOF.
Well last night the MOF replied( I deleted the topic only), frustrating beyond belief:
Thank you for your access to our web-site. Unfortunately, we do not have any legal/administrative authority to discuss XXXXXX policy with any parties.
So they politely told me to F-off & at the same time confirm they are just doing nothing for Japan!
The rot continues & the enemy is the govt, bureaucrates, we are screwed!
JT you need to fix the quote, bold etc functions they often just dont work.
0
Jack Stern
I agree with GW 's frustration at the government and other beaurocratic agencies which are embedded in rule crazy outmoded ways of thinking. One wonders what will happen to the entertainment industry like movie theaters that continually show few movies other than what they think you'd like and have an audience of five or so at each show. Slightly off the subject but relative to the thinking style.
2
Nicky Washida
Can hardly blame the Japanese for their apathy and lack of fighting spirit. Even laboratory rats eventually learn that when you bang your head constantly against a brick wall, it hurts and nothing ever changes so why continue doing it?
The Japanese as a nation are being thwarted by a tiny minority who run the country and have made a lot of personal wealth out of maintaining the status quo. Get rid of that system and Japan has a future. Until then - best to just wear a hard hat.
4
Nicky Washida
Sorry just want to add: if the triple disaster and subsequent governmental BS, lack of food safety controls, lack of information, blatently wrong/withheld information, exposure of children to insane levels of radiation, protectionism, lack of help and support, (I dont think I need to go on) hasnt been enough to galvanise the Japanese into a level of dissatisfaction where they are openly protesting and demanding change, then quite honestly, I dont know what will.
5
Godan
One reality of Japan to share with you in relation to "dissatisfaction" and "The Way":
Where I live in Tokyo, there are two elementary schools equidistant from my home. Before my son entered 1st grade, my wife did her homework and found that one school had 39 students in one class. The other school had 8 in a class (both for 1st graders). Confused, my wife soon found out that the latter school was scheduled to be shut down due to lack of enrollment. i.e. the "shoshika mondai". Evidently, by law, there can't be more than 40 students in a class. At 40 they then have to bring in another teacher and make a new class. But since parents were told that the second school was scheduled to close, the powers-that-be simply made a self-fulfilling prophecy, i.e. there would have been more or less 20 in a class at each school but parents had given up when the official announcement was made.
My wife, never one to give up, appealed to anyone who would listen to her. For two years she wrote letters to the Mombunsho, local politicians, the mayor of Nakano, you name it. And not one of the elite gave a crap! Instead of having two smaller classes for better learning environments, the oyajis thought more students in a class = better! FYI, any political party here who says they care about education is lying! Not even the communist party or Komeito lifted a finger for my wife!
Recently, some people new to JT have been shocked at the pessimistic postings from some of us who have been in Japan for a long time. I agree some people here are always seeing the glass half empty, but others are just telling you like it is. There is much to love about my adopted homeland, but some things just don't make sense and it is a shame that, as Nicky said earlier, a tiny minority controls Japan and could care less what the public thinks or what would be best for the people of Japan.
PS The school that was shut down was renovated into a home for senior citizens. A great example of oyajis taking care of oyajis and not caring whatsoever for the future of Japan. Sad!
2
GW
Godan,
Really beggars belief some of this stuff.
I have often tried to explain to people in both social, work circles that while Star Wars has the FORCE, Japan has THE WAY LOL!!! You can sense around you, its everywhere BUT there isnt a damned thing you can do about it!
Way too much in Japan is controlled by THE WAY, free thinking, discussing alternatives, brain storming IS NOT ALLOWED
I too love Japan but the last decade has been brutal & I too was hoping that 3/11 wud bring MUCH needed change to Japan, allow it to re-invent itself, but sadly looks like its going to be an excuse to mess things up even worse.
It saddens me but if I knew 20yrs ago what I know know I wud have never stayed longer than a year here, but now the roots run deep making it hard financially as well as emotionally to get out, but I do dream about it.
I really hate being proven right over & over again about the rot we all face, i would love to be proven wrong, but its unlikely
0
fds
people on accept change in necessity and see necessity only in crisis - jean monnet
we're not there yet. when the government says it can't pay back its debt, we will be.
0
horrified
I totally agree with the above posters. I also really doubt the level of dissatisfaction right now is enough to start a revolution for change.
I also really liked my lifestyle in Japan -- being here for 15 years. The last few years have seen things get progressively worse financially, with employers using the poor economy as an excuse to squeeze more out of their employees. Then, with this new drop in economy we add to worries about health and the future education of our children, I can't see a whole lot of reason to stick around.
0
Jotter Verhaeghe
Great article :). It is indeed true that Japan has this type of inhibition. The Japanese have chosen to show their dissatisfaction by voting for a different party, but it didn't help. The system seems to indeed be too strong. To get at the top of the system, you need to work within the system for 20 years and let's face it, are you going to change a system that you followed for 20 years?
1
jeffrey
GWSep. 09, 2011 - 11:59AM JST Godan, I too love Japan but the last decade has been brutal & I too was hoping that 3/11 wud bring MUCH needed change to Japan, allow it to re-invent itself, but sadly looks like its going to be an excuse to mess things up even worse.
This was the silver lining I hoped for as well post-3/11. A lot of good came during the rebuilding of greater Tokyo after the Great Kanto Earthquake (less so after the Kobe quake), but then that was also a time of relative economic health in Japan.
I guess, historically, "gaiatsu" (the Meiji Restoration and the post- WWII occupation) has been the only real agent of change in Japan over the last 100 + years.
-4
ebisen
Renho Murata was (is) a very arrogant woman with an extremely limited IQ... Her ranting, (not only against the supercomputer) but against other science projects while she was responsible for the financial reform were among the most disgusting moments in Japan's politics... She was NEVER number one, so it's only natural for her to ask "what's wrong with being number two" .. Here's the answer - everything is wrong... We don't need leaders who are content with being number two - weaklings with no ambition...
0
as_the_crow_flies
Personally I don't know much about Renho and her politics, and I couldn't give a toss about her choice of jackets or hairstyle, but I agree totally with her question. Glad someone was just down to earth enough to point out the obvious. Except I must have got mixed up somewhere because I could have sworn Japan was now supposed to be number 3.
Anyway, why indeed sink billions into a mine's bigger than yours project? Wearers of darker, sweatier, less distinctive or stylish jackets might blench at the impertinence of this question. Perhaps they don't know some of Japan's other rankings in the world. I don't know much about baseball or football, but I think on academic standards in maths and science tests Yamato is something like tenth or fifteenth, livable cities, don't think there are many in the top twenty; university rankings? ... well down the list, not sure where exactly, and on women's rights it's somewhere between Sudan and Myanmar or somewhere at about the 100 out of 140 mark. Please correct me if I'm wrong, I don't have the exact figures with me right now. But heck, even on suicides, it's only something like fifth or sixth highest in the world. So boys PLEASE be dissatisfied! Let's get up to first on all fronts!!!!
Back to top