Kendo – A religion without a god?
TOKYO —
To mold the mind and body,
to cultivate a vigorous spirit,
and through correct and rigid training,
to strive for improvement in the art of kendo;
to hold in esteem human courtesy and honor,
to associate with others with sincerity,
and to forever pursue the cultivation of oneself.
Thus will one be able to love his country and society,
to contribute to the development of culture,
and to promote peace and prosperity among all people.
After about a year of practicing kendo, I started to feel a sense of déjà vu. At first I couldn’t put my finger on it, but I soon realized that kendo was treated like a “religion” by many of the people in my dojo. Now before I am a branded a blasphemer, please allow me to explain.
As I mentioned in my previous post, I was raised Catholic – Sunday school, parochial schools, you name it. And while it wasn’t necessarily “fun,” I now see the many benefits my upbringing in the church had on me. In addition to the obvious focus on the messages in the Bible and the teachings of Jesus, there was the sense of community and the routine of attending mass on Sundays as a family. This was then followed by the “breaking of the fast” with a nice brunch – again as a family. Of course, we were always dressed in our Sunday best, with our hair combed nicely, etc. Church was also a focal point for the community with bingo, bake sells, community outreach programs, and the aforementioned Sunday school often taught by volunteers from the parish. There is more, but for this article, I think you get the point.
Now for the comparison to kendo, as it is often practiced in Japan. To start with, there are the words at the start of this article. This is the Kendo Creed and in my mind, the message it carries is similar to what one would find in the New Testament. In particular, the values mentioned—“courtesy,” “honor,” “sincerity,” “peace,” “love of country,” and “prosperity”—are all ones that were stressed at one time or another by priests in the various sermons I listened to growing up.
Further, as I became closer to and made friends with the other members of my dojo, I was hearing more often than not that kendo was indeed a family affair. A common story was a father, mother, or both had grown up practicing kendo, “strayed,” but after marrying and having children, had decided to return and “share the word” with their own children. And as anyone who practices a martial art or sport will tell you, the need for consistency is one of the most important challenges to overcome. Just practicing once in a while is not quite a “sin” but it is frowned upon and realistically speaking there is probably no better way to get injured than to practice all out after a month or two away from a dojo. As such, it is a given to attend practice once or more a week.
So, the family will come to the dojo and if the mother or father is 4-dan or higher, it is highly likely that they will be called upon to help teach the children – including their own. While the parents are attending to improve their own kendo, they are also teaching the next generation. A metaphor for Sunday school if there ever was one, no? Even if the parents aren’t teaching, they will be in the respectful position of an “okaasama” or “otousama” and all of the children will be expected to be on their best behavior.
After practice, it won’t be unusual for the family to go out for a meal or join other families to break their fast. Kendo even has “retreats” or “gasshuku” where all of the various families will work together in planning the weekend getaway as well as participate actively. The “gasshuku” are often held in the summer when school is out and attended if at all possible.
But in all of the similarities between kendo and religion, I see one obvious difference: the lack of a god. A visit to many a dojo and one will find a Shinto shrine and/or a Hinomaru flag on a wall, and there is always the Zen aspect of any of the martial arts in the acts of meditation and reflection before and after practice. In fact, you will also observe some practitioners bowing to the dojo (a sign of respect one shows when entering or leaving) and their gear as an acknowledgement/thank you for the protection being afforded during practice. This aspect of animism, as far as I can tell, is about as close as one will get to the notion of a god in this “religion” of kendo.
As such, you will see an obvious lack of effort to convert anyone, or argument over whose god is the “real and only one,” and so forth. To be honest and speaking for myself, the creed and the implementation of it in the practice of kendo is a welcome approach to the instillation of various values into the members of society who decide to take it up. Does the absence of belief in a higher being preclude it from being an official religion – sure, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t deserve acknowledgment for the good it brings into this world of ours.
Thanks for reading. お疲れ様でした.
P.S. Putting my money where my mouth is, i.e. sharing my “religion” with my family, my sons have recently started practicing kendo. They attend a dojo with my wife and practice together. I am happy to say that they are enjoying themselves and look forward to going to “church” every week.





Order by Time Order by Popularity
35 Comments
Login to comment
0
ben4short
Intersting try, Eric, but a bit of a stretch. First of all, there is no notion of a "god" in Buddhism (and probably lots of other religions I'm not aware of), so why the big deal about "a religion without a god?" Secondly, why the need to create an analogy in the first place? Kendo is kendo, tea ceremony is tea ceremony, and soba is soba, the latter two having more in common with kendo than your Catholicism or my Judaism. One would have hoped that after so many years of kendo, you would have broadened your perspective to realize that the notion of "god" is infinitely greater than the narrow Judeo-Christian one you seem to subscribe to. Your essay and religious analogy feel forced and artificial to me.
2
Christina O'Neill
I never found any of the martial arts that my family and I participated in were even remotely related to any religious establishment. They were hard work, in regards to concentration and the development of self defence skills. They taught control and discipline, 40 or so pressups on your knucles for an infringement of rules and respect certainly maintained order in the dojo. i guess you wouldnt get that in the Catholic church upon confessing your sins.The only higher being in the dojo was the instructor, Sensai and all I can say is God help any of us who stepped out of line.
-3
Yardley
Enjoyed your article, Eric.
0
It"S ME
Ertic another well-written article.
Some MA are connected to religions most are not, said that anything can become your religion, IMO. People jut get hooked on the term "religion". ;) Not going into details why some JMA became classified as religions.
I have been to many gashuku even doing CMA here, usually what we learn there in 2-3 days is worth months at the local school as we are exposed to many teachers, different teaching styles and emphasises of the arts.
0
It"S ME
Gomen, misspelled Eric. Was typing too fast.
1
JapanGal
Thumbs up for Ben
3
Foxie
I think the God in MA is the spirit and the spirit is the sensei, the dojo and the art itself. Respect of everything and every creature is what comes to my mind, isn't that also ingraved in Buddhism and Shintoism? So, there is not 'one' God but many in other words. All religions come with ritualsbut what are rituals? They are just a combination of steps. You could say that all rituals are religious or not, depending on your feelings towards them. I can take a ritual bath or a normal bath, I can drink a ritual cup of tea or a normal one. I can make everything spiritual if I want to or I cannot. Maybe if I make something spiritual, I ease my mind and free myself of problems. If I say that now, the conclusion would be that religions are selfish because they only make me feel better, so I am selfish and doing Kendo is selfish too. I think it is better not to think so deeply about those things otherwise we all go crazy. And we shouldn't take things too seriously either but enjoy them more for what they are.
0
ben4short
Wonderful post, Foxie! Love your clarity and thought process. Mindfulness. We should honor god in silence and gratitude.
2
SamuraiBlue
Foxie, you're forgetting the one and foremost important one, one's self. In western religion it's always the fearful almighty God that is keeping check of one's behavior where as in the spirit of oriental martial arts it is only you to blame if you live up to your own expectations or not and being one's own strictest critic you keep yourself in check so you really don't need an almighty God to do it for you. Whether it be at practice or life in general you set your own standards and once setting them you have to reflect constantly on your own actions checking if you're living up to them and you only got yourself to blame with no devil or god to blame. That is what Do(道) means, following the path you set for yourself and to fulfill the never ending quest.
0
Foxie
That's pretty interesting, SamuraiBlue and reminds me somehow of the teachings of jihad: an internal struggle to maintain faith, a commitment to hard work and achieving one's goals in life.
1
SamuraiBlue
The sense of shame and the major reason for suicide here in Japan is probably the opposite side of the same coin I had written.
0
Godan
@SamuraiBlue - thanks for sharing your insights on this subject! In regards to the issue of suicide, it is interesting that you mention this. As most here on JT are well aware of, the highest rate of suicides is among men over 50 and yet in all my years of practicing kendo, I can't recall any sensei or other older practitioners taking his (or her) life. Having a 道 = a life saver? Makes sense to me.
0
ivarwind
As I see it, the main difference between kendo and religion, is that religion implies some sort of framework for how the world works. In many religions this takes the form of one or more gods pulling the strings or setting things in motion, but it doesn't necessarily result in family oriented Sunday schools. The hermits in antiquity would likely not have been very fond of spending time teaching children, even if they ended up having to teach their acolytes.
The creed does however bear quite some resemblance to some of the teachings (I think) of Confucius, and certainly implies that following the path does greater good than just enabling your own success or well-being.
But saying that it IS a religion, seems to come more from the late medieval Western viewpoint (the same viewpoint has arisen in other places) that one specific religion must control or at least supply moral values to both the ordering of society and the daily lives of the individuals - and thus anything that serves this or part of this purpose is a (possibly competing) religion - and the claim doesn't sit well with the East Asian and in particular the Japanese practice of religions as a, shall we say, non-exclusive aspect of life.
Finally I think even the most hardcore anti-theists would find it hard to be offended by kendo practice. :)
0
SamuraiBlue
@ Godan
I am sorry but you are not getting the whole idea. It is the ones who have conviction to their own standards that are the one's who are susceptible to suicide because they felt they had gone down way below their own standards that they cannot not excuse themselves for it. For example the recently deceased JR Hokaido CEO. He was ashamed of himself for not being able to manage the company which led to death of passengers at the accident which tarnished the good name of the company. We don't know if he was directly or indirectly responsible nor will we know which part he thought was inexcusable but he clear did not forgive himself for it. 道 a lifesaver? Can't really answer that question. I think the better question is which path are you willing to take? A wise sensei will always be willing to give a good suggestion to lead you to your destined path which I hope you will to your students and not seppuku as was once taught to be the graceful way to end since there should be no grace in life only hardship(試練) and trials along whichever path you take.
0
Godan
@Ivarwind - thanks for the comment. :-)
@SamuraiBlue - Hmm...interesting take on the sense of personal "standards". So, the hardworking, serious types are the ones calling it quits early? Not so sure about that. But I think we are moving a little off topic. Anyway, I really like what you are sharing. Thanks for the food for thought.
3
Frungy
At their core all religions simply offer a code for living, but most people miss this aspect because they're so busy focusing on the "mystical" portions. For Catholics if you go to church every week, go to confession, etc, then you are being "good". For Muslims it's keeping "halall" (pure). For Jews keeping Kosher. For Buddhists it's trying to avoid Karma. All religions share this common element, and while they may differ on the precise nature of the reward the fact is that the vast majority of followers are so stupid that they completely miss the obvious day-to-day benefits of these codes and spend way too much time focusing on the mystical elements. For example, the codes for Jewish Kosher food and Muslim Halall food are so similar because they evolved from the same environment, a hot desert climate where food spoiled quickly and, for example, mixing meat and dairy was a sure way to end up with food poisoning. Likewise Christians so often miss Jesus' single real commandment, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you" (my preferred paraphrasing of this is, "Don't be dick.") that it is really stunning, and the number of bible-thumpers out there who focus on esoteric passages in the bible that support them harassing others... while ignoring the core message.
My point is that "god" isn't really the core issue in 99% of what most religions preach, most of the rules around religion are actually common sense things that evolved from the need for social harmony and basic health. Nowhere can this be seen more clearly than in martial arts. I've studied a fair number over the years, and while they do use "spirit" and other pseudo-mystical terms the bottom line in most cases is that the codes of behaviour exist for darned good common sense reasons. For example the entire set of theory around medians and chakras in martial arts has a more solid basis in good engineering, physics and anatomy than it has in the mystical. If you understand how your body moves, around what points your center of gravity pivots, etc then it's much easier to remain balanced while delivering maximum force... of course 1000 years ago the vocabulary didn't exist to describe these concepts, and the message has become a little garbled since then. Similarly dietary and health advice mostly starts off simple, e.g. "You might want to quit smoking if you want to be able to do those 100 push-ups, and progressively becomes more complicated and specific, e.g. days of fasting and eating specific foods high in calcium before moving onto more demanding exercises like knuckle-jumping-pushups. These are again just common sense, experience having shown people how to prepare your body best for a specific exercise.
As for the community-spirited aspect you see in martial arts... well, it's just common sense again, if your husband/wife/child is disappearing off every night to do something you know nothing about for 2 hours a night... soon enough most people get curious and want to know what it's all about. Inviting family members to retreats, getting them involved and showing them what their husband/wife/child spends so much time doing is just sensible and reasonable. Likewise public demonstrations, getting the entire dojo to pitch in to help with public projects, etc breaks down some of the fear and uncertainty that the public might have about having people training in a martial art (literally an art of war, one that was historically designed to kill people). Finally of course you need a stricter moral code for people who, when they lose their temper, are capable of killing someone with greater ease and efficiency than an untrained person. Once again, just common sense.
I can see how the author (correctly) drew an analogue between the codes of behaviour in martial arts and religion, but where I would offer a correction is that the author made the classic mistake of confusing common sense advice with mystical or religious teaching. The teachings of martial arts, if you take the time to actually look at them and ask the very simple question "Is there a good common sense reason for doing this?", well, sometimes it's taken a little research but I've always found at least one good common sense reason, and sometimes multiple reasons, with absolutely no reason to say, "It's magic!!!".
1
Foxie
Concepts such as mushin (無心), or "empty mind", are borrowed from Zen Buddhism and are considered essential for the attainment of high-level kendo. Fudōshin (不動心), or "unmoving mind", is a conceptual attribute of the deity Fudo Myo-O, one of the five "Kings of Light" of Shingon Buddhism. Fudōshin, implies that the kendōka cannot be led astray by delusions of anger, doubt, fear, or surprise arising from the opponent’s actions, collectively called "the four kendo sicknesses" (四戒, shikai, lit. four admonitions). Thus today it is possible to embark on a similar quest for spiritual enlightenment as followed by the samurai of old.
0
Godan
Foxie, you are giving away my next topic. No worries. ;-) Sincerely though, thanks for the posts. Frungy, too! Wonderful reading. :-)
-2
ben4short
Eric/Godan, you keep missing the point(s) because you seem to be addicted to linear thinking, which is anathema to everything Asian, from kendo to ikebana.
-1
Foxie
Sorry, Godan but I keep on asking myself now why they linked Kendo to religion. Basically, Kendo means the Way of the Sword and Kendo in its initial form is nothing more than fighting with a sword. We should ask ourselves what a sword is used for? Not for cutting bananas but the way I see it, it is a weapon for either defending yourself or attacking. So, basically a sword in the end is used for killing. The Kendo student practises furiously, thousands of cuts morning and night, learning fierce techniques of horrible war, until eventually sword becomes "no sword", intention becomes "no intention", a spontaneous knowledge of every situation. So, does that mean Zen is no religion or if it is a religion, why does it make killings harmless?
-1
Godan
Maybe, as you say Ben, I am missing something here, but all I was trying to say was that based on the Kendo Creed and the values we practitioners are striving for, it just seems to me that the men and women I practice kendo with approach it like a religion. I guess I am not thinking as deeply as others here. As I wrote in my column this time, I just see and experience many similarities to what it was like being raised in a church.
Ultimately, the point I was trying to raise was encapsulated in my concluding sentence:
Does the absence of belief in a higher being preclude it from being an official religion – sure, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t deserve acknowledgment for the good it brings into this world of ours.
In other words, I see kendo as more than just an exercise/sport and through the practice of kendo I have met some great people from around the world that regardless of gender, race, and nationality are able to come together, try to improve ourselves, treat each other with respect, and so on.
Thanks for your feedback. Eric
3
ben4short
Eric/Godan, understand completely. I salute your love and dedication to kendo, and your continued efforts to write about your personal relationship with it. Given the current state of our world, we should all be grateful for any activity or sport with the power to both transcend and transform us out of ourselves.
-2
miyazawa3
it is something odd, and funny..... just like they say, we are married but it is same sex. heee heee...
-1
SamuraiBlue
At the end what I am trying to convey is that you are yourself the god that you worship and and the body is the shrine which embody that god.
@Godan
What I have written is basically the teaching of Theravada Buddhism teaching that insight must come from the aspirant's experience, critical investigation, and reasoning instead of by blind faith. Theravadan tradition also emphasize heeding the advice of the wise, considering such advice and evaluation of one's own experiences to be the two tests by which practices should be judged. So yes, in away Kendo is related to religion just not the three major Abrahamic religions but of another teaching coming from a complete different root.
-2
miyazawa3
I count 1001 Religionssssss ..... but there is only one Divine...Religion....
2
LoveNot
I have seen in other sports people kiss the track and field area of competition, kiss the carpet or the sports apparatuses like swords with which they compete etc. I think they express their gratitude for fulfilling something and also their love of what they do. We can kiss not only a person but an object to express love and respect. I am sure programmers kiss their computers. I do not think it is a respect to a God but feeling of satisfaction, hope of success, gratitude when we do like this. Usually when people have the same hobby, and interests, they share the same habits and customs. We can compare this to a religion but it is to be more exact a sense of community, sense of same goals, thinking interests. Because not all people like religion, let us not give religious aspect of anything we do.
2
warnerbro
I agree. Kendo and other Japanese martial arts are steeped in the trappings of Shinto and Zen, particularly the Rinzai sect. That's why they feel like religious practice.
1
tokyokawasaki
Yes, it's called Atheism.
1
SamuraiBlue
tokyokawasakiOct. 07, 2011 - 02:25PM JST
Yes, it's called Atheism.
A completely oxymoron reply don't you think, considering divine points to god when Atheism means not believing in them. Another point is that Atheism isn't a religion since religion is a theology worshiping god which Atheism completely rejects.
0
ben4short
Samurai, I don't think tokyokawasaki intended her statement to be taken literally. If I may add my interpretation: the most perfect and absolute religion can only be the absence of religion . . . hence atheism. And I think she's spot on.
0
SamuraiBlue
ben4shortOct. 07, 2011 - 08:22PM JST; Samurai, I don't think tokyokawasaki intended her statement to be taken literally. If I may add my interpretation: the most perfect and absolute religion can only be the absence of religion . . . hence atheism. And I think she's spot on.
In which your reply is oxymoron as well, since religion is worshiping a divine entity which Atheism does not and absolutely rejects the idea, it maybe a belief system but it sure is not a religion. Another thing about Atheism is that it also rejects the idea of a soul and/or spirit so if you believe in those then you are not an Atheist either.
0
tokyokawasaki
@SamuraiBlue: I believe in love, life, death, reproduction and evolution. Everything else is pure fantasy to make life more comfortable to live.
0
SamuraiBlue
tokyokawasakiOct. 08, 2011 - 10:19AM JST; @SamuraiBlue: I believe in love, life, death, reproduction and evolution. Everything else is pure fantasy to make life more comfortable to live.
Meaning you do not have faith in religion, a spirit and/or soul, good for you. There is nothing wrong nor being ashamed about it. I'll say it again Atheism is not a religion since it does not place faith to anything that cannot be presented and/or proven through science.
0
tokyokawasaki
I know atheism is not a religion. What I said before was sarcasm :)
You said: "Meaning you do not have faith in religion, a spirit and/or soul, good for you". which loosely translated means "You are not gullible" or "You do not believe in fantasies, because you are mentally strong enough to accept the amazing and beautiful world and universe we live without needing to believe in myths and mind control which came from the middle ages'...
If that's what you really meant to say to me then thank you.
0
SamuraiBlue
Neither I guess. I do not believe that either are superior to the other. I do not believe in an almighty god nor do I believe that present science had uncovered all the secrets of nature.
The idea of "Soul and/or spirit" is seriously being considered by combining quantum physics and neural science in which the brain maybe utilizing quantum mechanics for computing in which case our thoughts will remain through quantum entanglement meaning our ancestors were right but did not possess the right language to convey that idea in a more logical matter.
Back to top