Japan collective self-defense should include others, not just U.S., says Abe adviser

The requested article has expired, and is no longer available. Any related articles, and user comments are shown below.

  • -7

    some14some

    The right to exercise collective self-defense should be applied “to any country which is very close to Japan”, Shinichi Kitaoka,

    perhaps, no country is close to Japan either by distance or heart.

  • -8

    BertieWooster

    Is this a typo:

    The article states:

    Japan should change the interpretation of its constitution to allow its military to defend not only its ally, the United States

    But it makes more sense if written like this:

    Japan should change the interpretation of its constitution to allow its military to defend its only ally, the United States

  • -11

    J.basher

    What ally, might turn around and do a sneak job again.

  • 1

    OssanAmerica

    Regardless of whether collective defense with nations other than the U.S. flies or not, collective defense with the United States will invariably force it because of U.S. collective and bilateral agreements with other nations. So it's neither here nor there. The truth is that the U.S., Australia, Southeast Asian nations have formed a block to prevent China from doing what it has declared; to take control of the entire South and East China Seas and the navigation routes contained therein. Should a conflict occur in this regard Japan is going to be involved whether it likes it or not.

    some14someNov. 11, 2013 - 07:12AM JST "The right to exercise collective self-defense should be applied “to any country which is very close to Japan”, Shinichi Kitaoka," perhaps, no country is close to Japan either by distance or heart.

    Very dumb comment .

  • 2

    yokohamarides

    I just watched Kitaokas speech and wasnt impressed. "We should change the constitution because it is wrong", "Not having the right to collective defense is stupid", The concerns of the Koreans don`t need to be taken seriously because "The Koreans are an emotional people" etc. How could someone in a position of such importance be such a lazy thinker? This is the way a child supports his opinions.

    You can watch the entire speech here - http://vimeo.com/77183187.

  • 2

    sveinnyves

    There is a saying that good people always unite with good people.

  • 1

    bass4funk

    @Bertie

    Japan should change the interpretation of its constitution to allow its military to defend its only ally, the United States

    Always the dreamer.

  • 0

    OssanAmerica

    I would say that the China supporters who claim that Japan has only one ally can only substantiate that claim if hey define "ally" as another country with a defense agreement. But then by that definition, what "ally" does China have?

  • 2

    tyvtgo1US

    Japan has the right of any nation to counter those threatening them and the US has been in support of Japan being more actively engaged in its defense. As for allies, Japan has many, all western nations are an allie of Japan, who are you people trying to fool here about the US being Japan's only allie? Japan is a well established partner of all developed nations based on human rights and rule of law within the country and with in international laws, which is not able to be said for some of its neighbors which we could very pointedly point out. Just look at who is nuclear equiped in East Asia.. China and their partner, North Korea, plus there is Russia, plus there are those regimes that China and Russia has continually blocked resolutions in the UN from becomming nuclear armed by vetoing resolutions or causing resolutions to be so watered down that resolutions passed has no real affect of stopping these rogue nations from becoming nuclear. China's moves in the UN is a prime example of that when we look at North Korea, so see who China supports???? Which leads to another stupid issue about South korea and its relationship with Japan today. But that is another topic. Japan is a well developed country economically and socially, and just another positve partner in the family of the international community, lead by their people and should never stay victim to the oppression or aggression of those that show aggression towards them? And yes all in East Asia and South east Asia needs to form and complete a defense treaty to oppose the aggression, not only of the retoric of North Korea but the actions of CHINA! This is only logical with what we have seen coming out of China with their actions and threats of their continual building massive build of their military that is directly aimed at Japan. Should Japan just sit by and watch and accept China's aggressive acts against it and its threat! DEFINITEL Y NOT! The only one I actually see against Japan at this time with Japan expanding its forces is,, yeah you got it... CHINA! the country that has been using its new found might against Japan and others in Sout East Asia that them too look for Japan to build and counter China's mass building of power and expansionist actions and aggressive actions against all in Asia. It is time Japan, time to wake up and stand tall!

  • 3

    AkashiAussie

    It looks like Japan has its sights set on North Korea. I don't think Abe wants to sit idly by the next time North Korea start playing with their missiles and threatening other nations. Also, China are potentially in the cross hairs too methinks.

  • -1

    Guru29

    The proposed shift is part of Abe’s long-term agenda whose end point is revising the constitution’s pacifist Article 9

    Scrapping the pacifist constitution and getting rid of US control is only one of the long-term agenda of the LDP and other rightists. The other task that they have been trying to accomplish since they regained control of Japan in the 1950s is to revive State Shinto (Yasukuni cult).

  • 2

    Mike45

    wow we have come a long way since "Japan shall forever be banned from having a standing army navy or air force" to "japan should change the interpretation of its constitution to allow its military to defend not only its ally, the United States, but also other countries whose interests are closely intertwined with Tokyo" This comedy is really getting intense!

  • 5

    Thunderbird2

    The world will see the real Japan when it reels it's ugly head. Only China can prevent Japan from repeating what it did 70 years ago in Asia!

    See? This is the kind of mentality that's not helping matters at all.

  • 0

    Asian2013

    @Thunderbird2- so we in Asia should support Japan in its military build-up so as to help matters?

  • 2

    gelendestrasse

    It makes sense that Japan would seek allies in countries who share the same concern for the rule of law in the area.

  • -1

    superbird1

    @Asian2013 and others of your ilk. Yes you should! 100%. Because the alternative is going to be far far worse in the extreme.

  • 1

    OssanAmerica

    Mark my words, South Korea will want to benefit from Japan adopting "collective defense". They are the ones still technically in a state of war.

  • -1

    nigelboy

    Mark my words, South Korea will want to benefit from Japan adopting "collective defense". They are the ones still technically in a state of war.

    Actually, South Korea is not even a signatory to the armistice agreement. It's funny that SK wanted U.S. to hand over the command much earlier but SK wanted to delay hence the current 2015 timetable. U.S. should just pull out of the Korean peninsula so no need for Japan's involvement in the collective defense.

  • 2

    OssanAmerica

    Presumably, Japan will naturally have the right to exercise or not exercise collective defense, South Korea really needs to get it's act together and reach a bilateral security agreement with Japan. Naturally it will never happen with the current Park administration of course.

Login to leave a comment

OR
  • African Speaking Sales manager

    African Speaking Sales manager
    JPC TRADE CO.,LTD. (株式会社JPC)、Tokyo
    Salary: ¥200,000 ~ ¥450,000 / Month Negotiable Basic Salary + Incentives
  • Recruitment / HR Generalist

    Recruitment / HR Generalist
    Temple University, Japan Campus - テンプル大学ジャパンキャンパス、Tokyo
    Salary: Commensurate with experience plus transportation from/to TUJ
  • Program Assistant

    Program Assistant
    Temple University, Japan Campus - テンプル大学ジャパンキャンパス、Tokyo
    Salary: Commensurate with experience plus transportation from/to TUJ
  • Portuguese Speaking Sales Manager

    Portuguese Speaking Sales Manager
    Autocom Japan (オートコムジャパン株式会社)、Kanagawa
    Salary: ¥270,000 ~ ¥800,000 / Month Commission Based
  • Interim Administrative Systems Support Lead

    Interim Administrative Systems Support Lead
    Temple University, Japan Campus - テンプル大学ジャパンキャンパス、Tokyo
    Salary: Commensurate with experience plus transportation from/to TUJ

More in Politics

View all

View all