China reneges on Internet freedom during Olympics
BEIJING —
The Beijing Olympics were plunged into another controversy on Wednesday as China announced a backflip on Internet freedoms for the thousands of foreign reporters covering the Games.
China’s decision to reverse a pledge on allowing unfettered web access proved an embarrassment for the International Olympic Committee (IOC), which had repeatedly said foreign press would not face any Internet curbs in Beijing.
It was also the latest in a long line of issues to have tarnished the run-up to the Olympics, which start on Aug 8, following controversies over pollution, human rights and terrorism threats.
Beijing Olympic organizing committee spokesman Sun Weide triggered the latest public relations flare-up when he confirmed foreign reporters would not have access to some sites deemed sensitive by China’s communist rulers.
“During the Olympic Games we will provide sufficient access to the Internet for reporters,” Sun said.
However “sufficient access” falls short of the complete Internet freedoms for foreign reporters that China had promised in the run-up to the Games.
Sun specified sites linked to the Falungong spiritual movement, which is outlawed in China, as ones that would remain censored for the foreign press at Olympic venues.
He did not identify any others but reporters trying to surf the Internet at the main press center for the Games on Wednesday found a wide array of sites deemed sensitive by China’s rulers to be out-of-bounds.
These included sites belonging to Tibet’s government-in-exile and Amnesty International, as well as those that had information on the 1989 Tiananmen massacre in which the military used deadly force to crush democracy protests.
The head of the IOC’s press commission, Kevan Gosper, said on Wednesday that he would take the matter up with Chinese officials.
“I will speak with the Chinese authorities to advise them of the restraints and to see what their reaction is,” he said.
Australian Olympic team chief John Coates, who is also an IOC member, expressed frustration with China’s Internet about-face, pointing out that the Chinese authorities had gone back on one of their “key” Olympic promises.
“It certainly is disappointing… I think it’s a matter that the IOC will take seriously,” Coates told reporters.
Two weeks ago, IOC president Jacques Rogge insisted there would be no censorship of the Internet.
“For the first time, foreign media will be able to report freely and publish their work freely in China,” he said.
“There will be no censorship on the Internet.”
The IOC late Wednesday denied knowing in advance of China’s plans to restrict the Internet for the 20,000 reporters covering the Games and said it was pushing for curbs to be lifted.
IOC spokeswoman Giselle Davies had said earlier that the IOC had been made aware of China’s plans to censor the Internet in previous talks with the Beijing Olympic organizing committee.
However, she later clarified her statement to say that the organizing committee, when referring to Internet restrictions, had spoken only of pornographic sites and sites sensitive for national security reasons.
“It would be incorrect to say that we knew in advance that China was to restrict certain sites and we are pushing for those restrictions to be blocked,” Davies said.
“They were talking about restrictions that are similar to those that exist in other countries.”
Gosper earlier Wednesday told the South China Morning Post that the IOC knew some sites would be blocked.
“Recently, I have also been advised that some of the IOC officials had negotiated with the Chinese that some sensitive sites would be blocked,” the Hong Kong-based newspaper quoted Gosper as saying.
“If you have been misled by what I have told you about there being free Internet access during the Games, then I apologize.”
Reporters Without Borders, the Paris-based press freedom group, said it was surprised the IOC had kowtowed so easily to China’s leadership over web access.
“When China applied to host the Games they promised total press freedom and that must include Internet access,” said Vincent Brossel, the group’s Asia director.
“What a total humiliation this is for the (IOC president) Jacques Rogge. How can the IOC be so weak and feeble?”
Wire reports






Order by Time Order by Popularity
51 Comments
Login to comment
0
nimbus
Restricting access to some websites is just part of the plan. The Chinese communist government is actually trying to spy on what you are typing on your keyboard. Check out the article on the attached link. Talk about invasion of privacy.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080729/apongoco/chinaspying_2
0
Scrote
The IOC is just another business. Like other businesses that operate in China they are prepared to tolerate the restrictions on freedom of expression and abuses of human rights that take place in that country, whatever they may say to the contrary.
The IOC just want the cash, they don't care about censorship, they don't care if the Chinese army runs over its own citizens with tanks. They don't care about anything except the money. Profits come first.
0
some14some
Exactly.
0
tkoind2
Shock and dismay!!!
Did anyone really expect China to revolutionize her political, social and human rights policies just because the Olympics were awarded? After granting Beijing the rights to host, what exactly could the IOC or anyone else have done to force China to keep their promises? All China had to do was play along until it was too late. Which is exactly what they did.
So 10 points to China for playing the rest of the planet like a piano. 10 points to corporations for seeing only profits and opportunities to keep making money there. And 10 points to those supporting the Olympics for supporting the next worst example since the Berlin Nazi hosted games.
Sadly no points for the Chinese peasants who will go on suffering losses thanks to the games. No points for farmers and people pushed off their land to make way for development. No points for people hoping to have a little more freedom. No points for the press or media who will be herded around to where the state wants them to be. No points for Uyghurs, Tibetans and others who will carry on being oppressed. No points for freedom, liberty or human rights at all.
Are't we tired of oppressive states and greedy companies winning all the points while the vast majority of other people are ignored or suffering?
Boycot the Olypics. Don't watch it, don't buy sponsored products, don't encourage it and spread the word to boycot it and send China a message that we see through their veneer.
0
thepro
Shock. I thought that communist country was really going to open up to everyone.
0
OssanULTRA
Is it too late to just cancel this whole thing and do it somewhere else?
0
tkoind2
OssanULTRA. Maybe too late to move it. But not too late to just forget the whole thing.
0
LIBERTAS
"The IOC just want the cash, they don't care about censorship, they don't care if the Chinese army runs over its own citizens with tanks. They don't care about anything except the money. Profits come first." I agree, the IOC is probably the most corrupt entity welcomed by everyone. My solution to this internet access problem is simple. Just don't report ANYTHING about the games. By the time the opening ceremony is finished, and the Chi-Comms realize their golden chance for fame is a non-event, they'll recant.
0
thepro
Yeah, reporters really should refuse to report then.
0
swordfish2502
Sorry, the page you requested was not found.
The story or page you were trying to access may have expired.
censorship is everywhere!
0
Zybster
Nimbus, could you please give the link again, paying attention the slashes and other punctuation marks?
0
teaabe
ap report by john doe
yesterday, on ____, there is group (deleted) at (deleted) 'request' (revised) 'superior' (revised) treatment 'professional physical practitioners' (revised). (note lousy english).
what should have been - "yesterday, on the 15th of August, a group of textile laborers had been demonstrating at the IOC Village for improved working conditions and treatment for factory staff workers and paid overtime for delivery truck drivers. the demonstrators were immediately arrested and taken to a local jail. several were beaten and cuffed in the process.
0
tokyotom
its not like the US only "opts" in on Intl agreements when it sees fit China is just par for the course like the other big countries
0
escape_artist
Could nimbus's article be this one? It's possible JT's commenting eats special characters like underscores. The preview I did prior to posting here left them out.
China spying on Internet use in hotels http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080729/apongoco/chinaspying_2 or http://tinyurl.com/5hotye
Another related article from Yahoo News... http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20080729/plnm/olympicschinaspyingdc_1 or http://tinyurl.com/6cz5zv
0
kun
I am so not going to watch anything from these Olympics or buy anything from the sponsors.
0
DenshaDeGO
As I read this article I recall with amusement, all the people who, during the torch run, said angrily that politics should be separate from the olympic games and to "lay off" China.
0
RepublicofTexas
I don't think anyone outside of the IOC is surprised by this.
0
fds
typical of china. now what happened to those pro-china supporter who insisted that china does not restrict the internet?
0
thedeath
"kun" i am with you.
0
Chessnutroastin
How else is the Chinese gov't supposed to keep track of all the foreign devils? Apparently they've also gone back on their pledge to have breathable air for the athletes as well.
0
KyouNoNippon
China go back on it's word? I cannot believe it!
0
TonyUS
all I can say.. No surprise
0
undecidedbout08
Once again, Red China shows their true colors. At this rate it will take an Obama tour of their entire country to bring them into this century.
0
TonyUS
I think Athens should stillhave venues ready or not take much to get them ready. :)
0
TonyUS
I think Athens should stillhave venues ready or not take much to get them ready. :)
0
JoeBigs
You dont say, China reneging on it`s word! Never this story must have been made up by the evil freedom loving terrorist! China is a country of greeeeat honor it would never do such a thing!
Now back to the peoples liberation front for the advancement of CCP values.
Brought to you by Uncle Lings House of Internet Hacking.
0
delitachan
Oh gosh, China wants to control everything the people do...isn't anyone worried if China ever decided to take over the world?
0
captainjohann
Is Falungong rituals, Tibet protests, Uighur terrorism has anything connected to SPORTS OR OLYMNPICS.? I think china is doing what is correct for its image and security. Also China is not DEMOCRACY which everyone must know. It is a communist proletariat dictatorship which feeds the american market with cheap labour.
0
Kwaabish
Duh. The IOC looks like the big dunce once again. Did anyone actually think China was going to be a good venue?
0
thedeath
it lame saying that “china is doing what is correct for its image and security”, “China is not DEMOCRACY”
If anyone narrow enough, thing only what good for your self, accept only the old way you has been doing. Listen to no-one but your-self. and your think that limit the freedom of press and freedom of speech is good for your country why on earth you want to be the host of the international event where majority of people out here worship the freedom of speech and human-right?
and If the human-right and freedom of speech has nothing to do with Olympic, then why the communist said that they will improve it in front of the world when they bet for the game?
Olymipc is an excellence opportunities for every Chinese to show the world how beautiful she is, but their communist gov use it as an opportunities to show-off how arrogant and liar they are.
In return they got nothing back more than hates from the world. What a wash of opportunity!!!?
0
Rio
The Chinese are going to come out of these Olympics looking exactly as they should. Filthy environment, poor treatment of foreign spectators, blatant censorship of respected news outlets like the BBC...there is nothing to celebrate at these Olympics. The PRC is an embarrassment to humanity, and Beijing 2008 will make that plain for all to see.
0
thepro
China wants to come out onto the world stage but still doesn't know how to deal with issues other than through force
0
zzonkerr
Rio - you took the words right out of my mouth!
0
Nippon5
You can lead a horse to water but you cant make it drink...
Look close at the Olympic torch and you will still see the beast that is China`s goverment...
Its so sad cause chinese people are so damn cool!!
Rio you are right on mark
0
TettoeAung
Like the Chinese official said, neither the IOC nor the world know China. The Olympic Games for China is merely a commercial transaction so too for the IOC. First of all we have to ask how much the IOC will gain from the Games. Sure, the Olympics and politics shouldn't mix but wasn't it a political decision when China was denied of the Games because of it human rights records and the game given to Australia in 2000? If that is not politics then what is? I just pity those people who lost their homes so that Beijing can play host to the Games. Just because of oil in Sudan the people in Darfur have to suffer so too are those residents of China who have to suffer because of the Games. Long live the Olympic and long live IOC!
0
imagawa
How incredibly predictable. Why do so many of you sound so surprised & disapointed? This but the beginning, wait until we start getting reports about visitors being arrested, it will happen.
And if you think you can't do anything about this you are wrong, you can. send an email to every one you know & get them to do the same, blanc ALL coverage of the olympic games, spread it like a virus. Let China & the IOC have their games, in private.
And try to keep in mind it is only sport, your life does not depend on seeing it, & you country will win (or not) even if you are not watching it, they don't NEED you infront of a TV. That's what China, the IOC & the advertisers need, not the sportspeople.
0
ca1ic0cat
I have to agree, it looks like China is going to botch this opportunity to show themselves as a modern government. I guess we were all just being optimistic. Too bad they are reverting to their typical modus operandi.
0
RepublicofTexas
Despite China's attempts to use the Olympics to demonstrate their "arrival" as a modern nation, I think the Olympics is merely going to reinforce the world's view that China's still medieval despite her military arsenal.
0
nimbus
Sorry, I couldn't find the original article, but here's a link to a very similar article on LA Times. The article is dated July 30, 2008. BTW, I cut and pasted the links so there should not be any typo problems.
http://www.latimes.com/technology/la-fg-olyspy30-2008jul30,0,1618850.story?track=rss
0
nimbus
Here's an excerpt from the article I have linked in my previous post.
"These hotels are justifiably outraged by this order, which puts them in the awkward position of having to craft pop-up messages explaining to their customers that their Web history, communications, searches and key strokes are being spied on by the Chinese government," Brownback said at a news conference...."
The problem goes beyond the Olympics. Think of what happens when the Olmpics is over. Do you think the communist government would allow the hotels to get rid of their monitoring programs? I don't think so. Which will mean all travelers to China would be subject to complete monitoring by the communist government on their internet use. Do you want them to know your passwords to your email accounts (person and business), online banking accounts, e-trade accounts, etc.?
Industrial espionage would be so easy. Don't forget a lot of companies in China are entirely or partly state owned.
This is very bad.
0
thepro
Well, I won't be visiting there anytime soon.
0
FairandBalanced
Bush should have a firm talk to the Chinese and express his displeasure with this.
This would surely presuad the cHinese to change their mind, and people could use the internet safely.
0
imagawa
FairandBalanced at 07:15 AM JST - 1st August
"Bush should have a firm talk to the Chinese and express his displeasure with this.
This would surely presuad the cHinese to change their mind, and people could use the internet safely."
You wrote this as a joke right?
The rest of the world think Bush is an idiot, why should China think any diffrent?
0
FairandBalanced
imagawa- Heck!! THe rest of the world admire and respect Bush. What media outlets do you use, only socilaist one? Bush is thought of with great respect by the average Chinese, who see him as a beacon of peace and prosperity.
The internet should be free duribg the Olympics, go on GW sort out China.
0
FairandBalanced
UnagiDon_ Heck!! My comments are a joke!! What is thsi pick on the moderate guy? Why have all the liberals got it in for me?
I believe Bush has to persuade China to do the right thing and bring freedom to the Olympics.
0
thepro
I don't think he's joking. He's just a kid maybe?
0
rajakumar
China is one party government. If it gives total internet freedom, it will affect their systems.
China is not the USA, with dual political leadership systems, that change to republicans or democrats. China and Russia are different political systems, they were cold war(iron curtain) isolated nations.
They need more time, Russians have only recently began in good opposition political systems with Kasparov(Democratic party of Russia).
Democrat party of Russia(DPR) won only 0.13 percent of votes in 2007 elections. If we asking for changes too fast, we are asking too much, and too fast.
0
Blue_Tiger
Should anyone be surprised, that a hardened Communist regime with control over its media would allow full media freedom? Red China made all sorts of promises, none of whic she has kept, in order to snag the `08 Olympics. It'd serve her right if this Olympics becomes the worst on record....
0
vawiha
I don't see what all the fuss is about. People know what China is like! No big surprise. China is a sovereign country! Does anyone think that China will kowtow to the West? The Olympics is just a big tax write-off for large corporate sponsors. In Vancouver, the homeless in the downtown core need shower facilities, but can they get them? No, but millions can be spent on constructing highways, sports venues, and locker rooms and shower facilities for athletes that will use them for 2 weeks. Why not focus our criticism on the real problem with the Olympics?
0
imagawa
The olympics is sport, sport sucks in the suckers who get sucked in by the advertising so the advertisers pay out big money, but only because the suckers are there watching.
China never intended keeping it's promise on free internet access & those that believed they would did so because it let them of the hook when it came to China getting the olympics in the first place. They should never have been allowed to host the olypics. Now the big money advertisers are making all their silly excuses.
Yes, I know, don't mix politics & sport, get real, most of the suckers just want to watch sport & don't give a damn. Their sport & their country are more important than anything else. Little people with little minds, but a lot of them to keep the advertisers happy. Money, sport & politics, what a very sick mix? Welcome to China suckers.
0
rajakumar
1 DAY(less than 24 hours) TO GO for Beijing 2008 sports competitons.
Back to top