Monday May 28, 2012

China's Wen vows to punish those blamed for train crash

BEIJING —

Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao pledged Thursday to “severely punish” those responsible for a deadly train crash that has sparked public fury and triggered fears over the safety of high-speed rail.

At least 39 people were killed and nearly 200 injured when two trains collided Saturday on the outskirts of the eastern city of Wenzhou, in the worst accident ever to hit China’s rapidly expanding high-speed network.

Wen, a popular figure with China’s masses, visited the scene of the crash as the government tries to assuage mounting anger which has dominated the media and the blogosphere in recent days.

“We will severely punish those responsible for the accident and those who hold responsibilities of leadership in accordance with the country’s laws,” said the premier, who has ordered an “open and transparent” probe into the incident.

The accident has raised questions over whether safety concerns may have been overlooked in China’s rush to build the world’s biggest high-speed rail system, a feat it has achieved in just four years.

China’s state-controlled media has been unusually outspoken in its coverage of the accident, defying directives not to question the official line.

A comment piece on the front page of the People’s Daily, the Communist party mouthpiece, said Thursday that China “needs development, but does not need blood-smeared GDP.”

“Development is of overriding importance. But development should not be pursued at all cost,” said the article, which was attributed to “the newspaper’s commentator.”

The Chinese company that designed the signalling equipment for the train line apologized on Thursday after a senior railway official said “flaws” in the system caused the crash.

“We express deepest condolences to the dead and a most sincere apology to the injured and families of the dead,” the Beijing National Railway Research and Design Institute of Signal and Communication Company said in a statement.

Shanghai Railway Bureau head An Lusheng earlier told investigators that the system “failed to turn the green light into red” after being struck by lightning, the first public admission the Chinese-made equipment was at fault.

Wen, who typically makes high profile visits to disaster sites, told reporters in Wenzhou he would have visited earlier but had been in bed sick for 11 days, the state Xinhua news agency said, without revealing the nature of his illness.

His public admission of illness was a highly unusual move in China, where the health of top leaders is considered a state secret, apparently due to concerns that sickness might affect the appearance of stability in the party.

But photographs on the central government website of Wen meeting a Japanese delegation the day after the crash appeared to contradict his claim. Analysts said this may suggest leaders had disagreed over how to handle the disaster.

Wen also called for efforts to “make China’s high-speed railway exports really safe” after observers said that the accident could scupper Beijing’s ambitions to sell the technology overseas.

Three senior railway officials have already been sacked over the disaster, and Beijing has ordered an “urgent overhaul” of national rail safety.

But that has done little to calm the furious response from the public and the media.

Anger has been compounded by allegations that authorities tried to cover up evidence by burying the wreckage, although officials said this was to help rescuers access the crash site.

Thousands of people have posted on China’s hugely popular micro-blogs, demanding to know why the driver of the second train, who was killed in the accident, was not told to stop in time.

China has ploughed huge sums of money into its high-speed rail network, which covered 8,358 kilometers by the end of 2010 and is expected to exceed 13,000 kilometers by 2012 and 16,000 kilometers by 2020.

A new $33 billion high-speed link between Beijing and Shanghai opened to passengers amid much fanfare on June 30—a year ahead of schedule—but has suffered power cuts and delays.

The high cost of the network has sparked fears over corruption, and China’s state auditor has said construction companies and individuals last year siphoned off 187 million yuan ($29 million) from the Beijing-Shanghai project.

The revelation followed the sacking of former railway minister Liu Zhijun in February, who allegedly took more than 800 million yuan in kickbacks over several years on contracts linked to the network.

© 2011 AFP

  • 0

    paulinusa

    “We will severely punish those responsible for the accident and those who hold responsibilities of leadership in accordance with the country’s laws,” said the premier, who has ordered an “open and transparent” probe into the incident."

    What can you say about this statement?

  • 0

    Pukey2

    I only hope Wen Yeye is sincere about all this. I don't want to see people (scapegoats) being punished just for the sake of it. I'd like to see them learn real lessons from this, punish those who were really responsible and make sure this doesn't happen again.

    His public admission of illness was a highly unusual move in China, where the health of top leaders is considered a state secret, apparently due to concerns that sickness might affect the appearance of stability in the party.

    I wonder whether Jiang Zemin is still alive. Last I heard, he was reported dead by the HK media a few weeks back, then absolutely nothing. Media blackout on the mainland.

  • 4

    TumbleDry

    Well, responsibilities are going to be buried with the train cars.

  • 3

    freakashow

    Why in the world would you quickly try to bury the train wreckage without thoroughly taking the time to search for all bodies (or possible survivors). I've heard that many Chinese are upset because many of their loved ones are still yet unaccounted for. Plus, it seems odd to me to bury something without finding the real cause of it first. Seems to me China just wants to quickly cover up its shame.

  • 1

    bass4funk

    By the statements, it probably translates to: scapegoats, find the fall guy. PR readjustments, get the bullets out, take care of business. Sums up to about what will happen.

  • 4

    Kwaabish

    A lot of lip service. I doubt that true transparency would take place, especially in light of the government orders to the media for them not to poke into investigating the cause of the crash. That plus how accurate and thorough can any further investigation be, especially in light of the fact that they buried the train cars into the ground, and prior to burying it, the heavy machinery was literally pulverizing the essential elements which should have been investigated, like those components of the train driver's seat and controls.

    In most modern nations, when a major transportation accident takes place, the authorities "preserve" the accident scene until thorough investigations (and resue operations) are complete. Then they take the pieces, fragments and components of the craft and try to piece them together in a different location.

    This is not what is happening in China....

  • 1

    Seirei Tobimatsu

    Don't punish the undertrained underqualified underlings. TRACE PUNISH those who got kickbacks or other other favors.

  • 1

    SamuraiBlue

    Seirei Tobimatsu

    Don't punish the undertrained underqualified underlings. TRACE PUNISH those who got kickbacks or other other favors.

    That is going to be difficult for Wen, especially when his aides were caught receiving bribes from rail development contractors suggesting he was accepting bribes as well.

  • 6

    chewitup

    The figurative cover-ups have gotten to the point that they actually physically buried the train cars less than 24 hours after the crash. This despite the fact that AFTER they had abandoned the search for survivors they found a two year old girl alive! Do you think they got all the bodies out?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011Wenzhoutrain_collision

    Now you know what will happen. A lot of people will be rounded up and get bullets to the back of the head before they even have a chance to proclaim their innocence and many of them will be innocent. And they and their knowledge too will also be literally and figuratively buried.

    Life is cheap in China.

  • 3

    chewitup

    I don't think the Chinese leadership realizes that there actually can be things more embarrassing than the train crash, and they can and will embarrass themselves more and worse.

  • 1

    gogogo

    You can blame all those people that took the kickbacks, but they wont, they'll go after the software engineer or something small like that to make it "all good".

    China stole this technology from Japan, there are articles on JT where the makers of the bullet train in Japan are suing the China companies that applied for international patents with their own technology.

  • 0

    gogogo

    Here's your problem

    "Kawasaki and other companies in Japan are currently challenging China's high-speed rail project for patent theft. The Chinese maker has been attempting to patent the same technology and alleged improvements"

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wenzhou_train_collision

  • -5

    smithinjapan

    And the people won't get away with it like the execs of JR West, or even get the humiliating 'nikkin kyouiku'... given the embarrassment the goverment is suffering via their moronic attempts to cover this up they're absolutely going to execute those 'responsible'.

  • 0

    marcelito

    Wen pledged to punish those responsible and have an open and transparent probe into the incident. The government has also moved to pay compensation to the victim,s families 3 days after the disaster.

    Whilst I,m no fan of China government,s human rights record, and while there will be no doubt efforts made by Railway ministry bureaucrats to cover up their butts, nevertheless at the top , Wen,s response appears decisive and aimed at transparency when it comes to disasters both natural ( eg. 2008 Sichuan earthquake) and manmade( this one ). What a contrast to we all know what.........

  • 6

    my2sense

    They are building way to fast and sloppy (cutting corners and stealing IP)... fake Apple stores, the works. I think I've seen a few buildings collapse and go up in flames because they are corrupt and greedy (get rich quick mentality). They put a few bullets in the heads of a few real estate developers already. I told people it wouldn't take them more than a year to crash one of these. Heaven forbid they get their aircraft carriers up and running... I give it a few years before it sinks and shoots down the wrong target. God save us from the Chinese.

  • 0

    Asagao

    Weeding and toilet duty awaits

  • 0

    timeon

    gogogo, even a non-specialist glance (and of course specialist opinion) all converge to the obvious fact that the shinkansen technology was stolen from Japan (initially bought, minor revisions made, then boasted as "Chinese super train"), and now they suffer from the issues associated with technology shortcuts: maintenance, compatibility, trained stuff, further developments.

  • 0

    timeon

    aa, and I say that just returning from China

  • 4

    freakashow

    And let's not forget the fact that China had recently claimed that "their train technology" had surpassed that of countries like Japan, France, and Germany. Add that to the fact that companies such as Alstrom and Siemens have also filed claims of patent infringement by the Chinese government on rail technology. All of this leads to a serious black eye for China. Could get worse if after digging up the buried trains, they find more bodies.

  • 0

    Kwaabish

    While China's Wen vows to punish those blamed for the train crash, apparently China is also vowing to punish those media outlets who investigate the cause of the crash... Lovely form of transparancy...

Login to leave a comment

OR

Follow us

More in World

View all

View all