France shocked by attack on Muslim graves
ABLAIN-SAINT-NAZAIRE, France —
Vandals desecrated 148 Muslim graves in France’s biggest war cemetery, hanging a pig’s head from one tombstone and daubing slogans insulting France’s Muslim justice minister, officials said Sunday.
President Nicolas Sarkozy expressed “profound outrage” at the “sordid” attack on the Muslim quarter of the Notre Dame de Lorette cemetery, near the northern town of Arras on Saturday night. He vowed that those responsible would be punished.
The cemetery is France’s biggest military graveyards and commemorates tens of thousands of victims of a series of long and bloody battles for control of northern France at the start of World War I.
The attack came almost exactly a year after a similar incident in which neo-Nazi vandals scrawled swastikas on 52 of the cemetery’s Muslim graves.
“This is the most inadmissible kind of racism and the president of the republic shares the pain of France’s entire Muslim community,” said a statement issued by the presidency. France’s Muslim community is Europe’s largest at around five million.
“This hateful act is also a attack on the memory of all veterans of World War I, beyond the faith of each one,” the statement added.
The state prosecutor for Arras, Jean-Pierre Valensi, said “the slogans directly target Islam and they gravely insult Rachida Dati, the justice minister,” who is the daughter of north African immigrants.
He said a pig’s head was hung from one of the graves.
Dati issued a statement condemning a “hateful act” that “hurts the memory of our dead, of the veterans who gave their lives for France”.
“Through its racist connotations, it is an assault on the values of the republic and an insult to all French people.”
Muslim community leaders were allowed to visit the scene on Sunday. “This is shameful to see,” said the regional head of the French Council for the Muslim Religion, Bahssine Saaidi.
“We need to work together… to stop this problem of racism,” he added.
“These are probably the tombs of heroes who fell in combat. This is a hateful, scandalous act, an insult to all Muslims,” Dalil Boubaker, rector of the Paris mosque, told France Info radio.
The MRAP anti-racism group said the attack was “a worrying sign of an ill that is gaining ground with a degree of impunity: islamophobia” and warned that France needed to face up to the problem.
SOS Racism said it was taking legal action to demand the dismantling of the neo-Nazi group behind the April 2007 attack on the cemetery.
Two youths aged 18 and 21, both members of the group, were jailed for a year over that attack. A 16-year-old also received a six-week prison sentence.
The Elysee said Sarkozy had called for a swift inquiry and “for those responsible for this act to be punished as they deserve.”
Around 100 French gendarmes were at the site to gather evidence. Jean-Marie Bockel, the secretary of state for veteran’s affairs, said the government would review security at Notre Dame de Lorette.
“This is horrific, and for the 90th anniversary of the end of the 1914-1918 war. This is worse than the last time, it is abominable,” said Jean-Paul Doue, one of 3,800 volunteer honorary guards at the cemetery.
Inaugurated in 1925, the Notre Dame de Lorette cemetery houses the remains of some 40,000 soldiers, half of them in named graves. The Muslim quarter includes 576 tombs, grouped together and turned towards Mecca.
Prior to 2007, there were four incidents involving the desecration of Muslim graves in northern and eastern France in 2004, and one in 2003.
There have also been several attacks on Jewish graves in cemeteries across France in recent years.
AFP








Order by Time Order by Popularity
21 Comments
Login to comment
0
sabiwabi
It seems someone is trying hard to get the Muslims to fight.
0
sabiwabi
My point is that someone is trying to get the Muslims enraged and I hope they are wise enough to see what is happening. Maybe this time that crypto Sarkozy wants to implement some measures against the “racaille” that he could not the last time they exploded.
0
greenteaonsens
This is just muslims getting a taste of their own medicine - they've been vandalizing Christian churches, graves and Jewish graves for years.
0
sabiwabi
It doesn't make sense if you think "much" = "most". But for those who are fluent in English, my sentence makes sense. You also seemed to have problems with "necessity" a few days ago.
Anyway, those people that I am apparently "anti-" towards are not even Semites. I'm sure you know this, so why do you continue to say that I am spreading anti-Semitism? Please have the courtesy to stop being so deceptive.
So what do think of the article? Do you think it is some racist nutcase who hates Muslims or someone with an agenda that wants a fight between the Muslim population and the remaining French population. I am surprised the moderator is allowing you to post comments that don't even address the article.
0
sabiwabi
They have? I must have missed that. Do you have proof?
0
sabiwabi
I agree they are racist freaks, but I suspect they are not specifically anti-Muslim.
0
sabiwabi
How do we know they are neo-Nazis? Things are not always as they seem. Just think back when there was a similar outcry from Chirac and the French public when a mother (pregnant?) and her child were allegedly attacked by a bunch of men and they drew a swastika on her stomach. It was big news. But it wasn't big news when they discovered it was a hoax, the security cameras did not support her story.
Helter, you actually read the stuff at davidduke.com, natvan.com, and stormfront.org? I heard they are quite awful.
0
romulus3
yeah. only Muslims would want Muslims to fight. No one else would want it. Its was a crime most probably committed by Islamic extremists in France wanting to gain sympathy for their cause by isolating the rest iof the Muslim population.
0
SuperLib
A grave can't defend itself. What a bunch of cowards.
0
skipthesong
I really hope this is not another hoax by people trying to cause or divert from problems. I got really caught up in the noose case at Columbia U only to learn that the incident may have been planted by the teacher targeted to divert the issue that she was being accused of plagiarism....
Least many of you not forget, there is a large anti-French movement going on in the Arab/Muslim neighborhoods lately with very disgusting Anti-French lyrics being played which could make anyone go over the edge.. So, if they really want to tackle racism, they need to look in all four directions; most of the so called Neo Nazi weren't born racists.
0
SuperLib
Sabi I'm surprised you aren't bringing out a conspiracy theory on this one. If these were Jewish graves being attacked you'd no doubt tell us it's the Israelis doing it to themselves in order to frame Muslims.
0
Nessie
I always wondered why religions that put so much emphasis on the soul have such fetishes when it comes to the empty, soulless husk that is a cadaver. Even the Buddhists, who make a point of de-emphasizing the body, descend into this fetishization by including relics in Buddhist statuary. In any case, regardless of the rationality of fetishing the dead body, it's wrong to desecrate someone's religion, regardless of its irrationality.
0
Hughgarse
Saw the photos of this.. utterly outrageous! disgraceful.
0
skipthesong
Hughgarse: give us a link...
0
outhousejt
Might be Zionist Satanists.
0
Helter_Skelter
There's a bit of irony here since Muslims supported Hitler and the Nazis during the WWII, lest we forget the Muslim Waffen SS.
0
sabiwabi
And lest we forget the Jewish bankers backing Hitler, and the many top Nazi officials who were Jewish. All this is "ironical" or strange only if you assume that the story of the Nazis being racist lunatics is true. I doubt that it is.
Whoever desecrated these graves is a disgusting racist freak, but I have no idea why exactly they did it. Did they have a specific agenda?
0
kinniku
Hi, again. No, you misunderstood. Your sentence doesn't make sense because you were originally claiming you don't tell people to go there for the truth.
Here again you are missing a very important point. Anti-Semitism and Anti-Islamism is not limited only to people who are 'Semite'. As with many other faiths, there are plenty of honest observers of both Judaism and Islam who are not as you call them 'Semites'.
As far as some comments about this possibly being some sort of hoax, I think this is a dangerous precendent in thinking about these kinds of attacks. Have there been rare cases of people making crimes up? Yes, however this should not lead us to rush to judgement about other cases. Most crimes and violence are not 'hoaxes' and most victims are in fact victims.
Well then, I am sure you can provide us with specific names then. If not, I guess we can assume you are making this up.
I don't doubt you doubt it is true. After all, you think Hitler didn't have 'a big hate for the Jews'. However, under Hitler, the Nazis rounded up and put Jewish people in camps solely because they were Jewish. That is racism.
Racism does not need a specific realistic reason. The reason is that racism is unreasonable. Hating people soley because they are of the Islamic faith is unreasonable.
Yes, their 'agenda' was desecrating Muslim graves. There doesn't need to be any more to it than that. I know you would love to somehow make a connection to Jewish people who support the State of Israel's right to exist. The problem is that except for a racist website, you cannot make such a connection.
0
sabiwabi
I did not miss that part. I actually quoted that same statement and responded to it at 3:40.
But you did also say (you can't deny it):
To think that something is possible is not rushing to judgement. You, however, seem to be rushing to judgment that there is nothing more to this event.
0
sabiwabi
I give up!
0
Helter_Skelter
Still waiting for you to provide specific names as kinniku requested.
Back to top