Monday May 28, 2012

Medvedev likens Georgia attack to September 11

MOSCOW —

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev on Friday likened the Georgian military assault on South Ossetia that led to last month’s war to the September 11, 2001 attacks on the United States.

“Almost immediately after these events it occurred to me that for Russia, August 8, 2008 was almost like September 11, 2001 in the United States,” Medvedev told Western foreign policy experts in Moscow.

Russia responded on that date and routed the U.S.-trained Georgian army in a conflict estimated to have killed hundreds of people on both sides and left tens of thousands more displaced in temporary camps.

In Tbilisi, Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili faced his most significant political challenge since the war as a former ally openly questioned his leadership and said she would set up her own party.

Exactly one month after an EU-brokered truce ended the conflict, Georgian officials said there was little sign on the ground that Russia had started pulling an estimated 1,470 troops from the main part of Georgia.

There were no signs of Russian troops moving from some of their bases near the oil terminal of Poti, the Georgian airbase at Senaki and the Inguri hydroelectric dam, which produces nearly half of Georgia’s power supply.

“It’s a dead zone here. The children are afraid. They stay at home because sometimes there’s shooting at night,” said a Georgian refugee in the village of Chale.

At other bases in western Georgia, soldiers appeared to be packing up to leave but Georgian Interior Ministry spokesman Shota Utiashvili cast doubt on the preparations, saying: “There has been no sign of a withdrawal.

“They are making preparations, we can see that, but in terms of reducing the number of personnel, it’s still the same as it was. Since last week they have been saying they are going to leave in a couple of days.”

Saakashvili, meanwhile, was warned he would face “tough questions” over his handling of the crisis with Russia.

Nino Burjanadze, a two-time interim president and former speaker of parliament, called for an independent investigation into the events leading up to Georgia’s five-day war with Russia.

“There is a time for tough questions. Of course what happened was a Russian provocation, but we need to know whether it was possible to not yield to this provocation,” she said at a news conference.

Saakashvili says he was provoked into the assault by repeated separatist attacks on Georgian-controlled villages and that Russian forces had already entered South Ossetia through the Roki Tunnel that connects it to Russian North Ossetia.

Georgia accuses Russia of effectively annexing South Ossetia and a second breakaway region, Abkhazia, but Moscow says it was defending many Ossetians who had been granted Russian citizenship since the 1991 fall of the Soviet Union.

After weeks of silence during and immediately after the conflict, Georgia’s vocal opposition has begun raising doubts about Saakashvili’s handling of the crisis.

Burjanadze, a former ally of Saakashvili, also said she was planning to form a political party to challenge the government.

Divided and lacking a charismatic leader, Georgia’s opposition has hardly been able to lay a glove on Saakashvili since he swept to power after the peaceful protests of the Rose Revolution in 2003.

Analysts say Burjanadze, once a Saakashvili loyalist, is one of the few Georgian politicians with the clout and experience to mount a serious challenge.

In Moscow, Medvedev further ratcheted up the war of words with the West, saying Russia would have responded in exactly the same way had Georgia been granted official NATO applicant status.

“I would not have hesitated for a second to take the same decision,” Medvedev told the media forum, according to participants.

NATO leaders said in April that Georgia would join at a future date, along with fellow ex-Soviet nation Ukraine. The stance has deeply angered Russia, fearful that its old Cold War foe is closing in on its borders.

“There were many useful lessons from 9/11 in the United States. I would like the world to draw its own lessons from what happened” in August, Medvedev said, adding: “The world changed.”

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov ruled out any discussion of Moscow’s recognition of independence for South Ossetia and Abkhazia—or on their status—at international talks set for October 15 in Geneva.

He also announced he planned to visit Abkhazia on Sunday and South Ossetia on Monday.

Wire reports

  • 0

    LIBERTAS

    Saakashvili played his hand, a dangerous game of chicken with Russia, and he lost. NATO, pushed by the US has ignored Gorby's counsel not to extend its membership up against the Kremlin's walls. Gone is the timid Cold War USSR, and emerged is a very powerful modernizing Russia, in no mood to be trifled with. The EU, NATO, the US and Japan need to come to terms with that new realpolitik. If you stomp on the Russian bear's tail, you'd better have a plan to deal with its teeth!

  • 0

    CavemanLawyer

    Open mouth, insert foot. If Mendelev bends over, I think I could help him get it out with another foot to another orifice.

    The attack was nothing like 9/11, and your attempt to score points off of it will garner you no pity, sir. Quite the opposite.

    --Ciroc

  • 0

    SezWho2

    I'm prepared to be understanding of Russian action in South Ossetia but I think Putin needs to take Medvedev to the woodshed and explain the difference between 9/11 and the Georgian attack in South Ossetia.

  • 0

    USNinJapan2

    Medvedev likens Georgia attack to September 11

    I can't type I'm laughing too hard...

  • 0

    SuperLib

    Ethnic cleansing....genocide.....9/11..... Seems that both sides like to use any hot button description they can think of.

  • 0

    Alinsky4prez

    I'm prepared to be understanding of Russian action in South Ossetia but I think Putin needs to take Medvedev to the woodshed and explain the difference between 9/11 and the Georgian attack in South Ossetia.

    Not so fast, comrade Sez. I think Vladimir is working up to something. If we are lucky the Ukraine will be the next breakaway state in need of "liberation".

    I think Vladimir is

  • 0

    bebert

    I believe Mendelev would have been more accurate if he had described Russia's defense of South Ossetia as being similar to the United States support of Texas vs. Mexico during the Texas war of independence.

    The point if valid though. Russian citizens with Russian passports were being savagely attacked by short-sighted Georgian troops. If an expatriate colony of Americans in, say Panama, was suddenly besieged by Panamanian troops, do you think the United States wouldn't send in troops to defend them like they did in Grenada?

    Good work Russia, the neo-cons are the enemies of all peoples everywhere. Someone has to put their paper tiger in its place.

  • 0

    jeancolmar

    The 9/11 metaphor is a weak one. The Georgian assault on South Ossetia was not the work of suicidal kitchen table terrorists but by a sovereign nation under orders from its head of state. A better analogy might be Pear Harbor. Both were sneak attacks and examples of reckless mendacity. Only Russia did not take over Georgia as the US and its allies took over Japan.

    It is good that within Georgia the war criminal Saakashvili is now being taken to task. Had he not decided to bomb the civilian population of South Ossetia's capital there would not have been a war.

  • 0

    USNinJapan2

    jeancolmar

    A better analogy might be Pear Harbor. Um no. Hawaii didn't belong to Japan as South Ossetia belongs (still) to Georgia. Pearl Harbor wasn't a domestic conflict into which the US stuck its nose.

  • 0

    bebert

    It is good that within Georgia the war criminal Saakashvili is now being taken to task.

    I agree, he needs to be dragged to the Hague, just like Milosovic, and put on trial for as long as it takes until he dies in custody.

    Oh wait, silly me, I forgot. New World Order goons of the USA and Europe aren't held up to the same standards of justice as is everyone else.

  • 0

    goodDonkey

    I am waiting for the Russian Duma to vote to recognize North Ossetia's independence.

  • 0

    SezWho2

    Alinsky4prez,

    What's with the "comrade"? Is there any justification for using that word that is appropriate to any point that you have made in your post? For that matter, what is the point of your post? that Putin is "working up to something"?

    What do you imagine that he is working up to? the "liberation" of the Ukraine? What scenario do you see in which that is a possibility?

Login to leave a comment

OR

Follow us

More in World

View all

View all